The Cumberland Throw

Rookie Watch 2023 Part 1 – SG Ball & Tarsha Gale

Welcome to the first instalment of Rookie Watch for the upcoming 2023 seasons across junior representative rugby league and the three major senior grades. Today we start with the two U19 competitions in the SG Ball and the Tarsha Gale where I have picked out a handful of players to keep an eye on.

I would like to stress that this is clearly far from an exhaustive dive into both squads and there could very well be critical contributions next year from players not covered. On top of that there are so many new faces to get to know that I simply can’t do them justice right now. From interstate signings like Kyen Murphy and the towering Lebron Tuala to an influx of Parramatta district talent who have each earned a shot at the elite pathways.

In Part 2 I will explore the key players in the NSW Cup, NRLW Development Squad and the Jersey Flegg Cup to watch next year. Notably, I have elected to forgo scouting the Harold Matthews squad on account of the significant roster churn but I do look forward to uncovering the identity of the team next year.

As always, I remind fans to stop and consider before they comment when it comes to the young men and women of the junior representative pathways. You may find that I lavish praise too strongly or don’t criticise pointedly enough (and that may well be true) but it is not for me to tear down any young man or woman chasing their rugby league dream.

SG Ball


Matt Arthur

Dummy Half

The Arthur surname is a heavy burden in the Parramatta pathways. Jake Arthur has been graded extremely harshly among fans for a 19-year-old half and unfortunately, I expect Matt Arthur to be treated the same. Thankfully he is a chip off the old block and is every bit as tough as his old man. That toughness is a vital part of his position of choice as well given the rigours asked of a dummy half in the modern game.

As you often see with sons of NRL coaches, Matt is a highly polished prospect respective to his age group. His service is crisp from the ground, he is plenty capable of stepping out of dummy half and driving the ball downfield while he often creates scoring opportunities in the red zone for his big men. Above all he is vocal. He is comfortable barking orders to his team mates and like any quality dummy half – revels in the verbal and mental battles on the field.

As with his elder brother, Matt is insanely fit having participated in the aerobic conditioning portions of multiple NRL preseasons. Obviously, this serves him extremely well on the field but means he is also forearmed with the knowledge of the physical standards professional footballers are held to. That is one of the burning questions facing every would be NRL rookie and plenty have flamed out when it is asked of them.

Whereas Jake is still growing into a rangier frame and is dealing with all the pros and cons that comes with that, Matt is much more compact. I think it will be easier for him to reach his peak physical profile and in turn he also projects comfortably into the physical architype of a modern dummy half.


Dom De Stradis


Dom De Stradis is the kind of player I can’t help but love as a fan and a former player. He brings the energy, the work rate and the hustle to every game. He sells out every set running tights lines and busts his backside off-the-ball. Typically these are your glue guys. The ones that hold the team together with their commitment to the team and the game plan. You love them, you need them but often they don’t grade out as ones to watch at higher levels of play.

With Dom though there are enough flashes of just a little something to warrant at least a bit of consideration. The odd explosive right foot step off a supporting line or a well-timed kick chase for a grubber. Individually moments that might be considered good but not great but moments nonetheless that add up when you look back.

At the very least I trust that he will a strong and reliable contributor to the SG Ball in 2023 but maybe…just maybe he can take the step further.


Richard Penisini


It isn’t easy playing in the shadow of an extremely talented elder sibling in rugby league. When your big brother is starring in deep playoff pushes and on the international stage for Tonga the shadow doesn’t get that much larger or longer. Yet, 2022 was a good year for Richard Penisini. The Eels struggled with cohesion and consistency in the Harold Matthews but his raw athleticism shone through both under the high ball and in his ability to win 1-on-1s and 2-on-2s out wide.

The duality of backline talent in the NRL is in an oddly polarising situation. On the one hand it has never been easier to plug and play new young outside backs into a first-grade backline. On the other, premium centres and wingers are becoming increasingly sparse as talented young outside backs increasingly gravitate to fullback in development pathways. Will Penisini is something of a positive outlier in this regard. It remains to be seen if Richard will be the same but there are certainly reasons to believe that he will make a long and legitimate push through Parramatta’s pathways.


Blaize Talagi


Blaize Talagi might be the most interesting and most difficult prospect to project in Parramatta’s pathways. In 2021 he starred in the Harold Matthews in the #6 as the junior halves partner to Ethan Sanders. He was given the reins to the Matts team this year and couldn’t quite replicate the highs of the year prior. Concerns of regression were understandable but Talagi finished the year in a *cough* blaze as he lit up the Australian Secondary Schools Rugby League Championships ultimately earning selection in the 2022 Australian Schoolboys Team.

He is as rugged a defender in the halves as I have seen in the age group and is comparable to Dylan Brown in that regard. Like Dylan he shines as a ball runner more so than the two other facets of playmaking and the rawness of his ball playing and kicking game open up discussion as to where his best position lies in the long term. Lock is a popular suggestion here. The rise of smaller, dynamic ball playing middles certainly jives well with Talagi’s talents and he absolutely has the toughness for the role. With that said I am curious to see how much polish Blaize himself can apply to his skillset at five-eighth in the next year or two.


Sam Tuivaiti


Big motors and big impact aren’t mutually exclusive in junior representative rugby league but they don’t always go hand-in-hand. Sam Tuivati is a young bull that possesses both in an equally big frame. Tuivati wowed in 2021 in his junior year of the Harold Matthews as a starting bookend and built on that effort in 2022 with selection in the 2022 Australian Schoolboys Team.

The young bookend has the internal accolades to match after scooping Players’ Player and Best & Fairest in the Harold Matthews as well as the Phil Carey Memorial Award for the best player in the Parramatta Junior District. Few young props are as well rounded as big Sam and even as a first-year member of the SG Ball in 2023 I expect him to feature prominently.


Tarsha Gale


Petalina Atoa


Roster mirroring is a practice you usually find between first and second-string rosters in order to minimise disruptions with like-for-like replacements. Be it coincidence, or a wry sense of humour from the footy gods, a curious case of roster mirroring between the NRL and Tarsha Gale in the front row occurred this year.

Ruby-Jean Kennard, Parramatta’s first ever Tarsha Gale-to-NRLW graduate, bears a strikingly similar athletic profile to Reagan Campbell-Gillard with the two bookends trending to the taller, leaner subset of prop forward. Her running mate and topic of discussion Petalina Atoa of course matches up closely with Junior Paulo with the stockier, explosive build. Just as ‘Reg’ and ‘Junez’ ran amok in the NRL this year, so too did Ruby-Jean and Petalina in the Tarsha Gale.

Ruby-Jean the relentless go-forward machine and Atoa the tackle-busting wrecking ball with an offload. It will fall upon Atoa’s shoulders to be the leading figure among the middle forwards next year but her mission statement on the field you would not change one iota. Be physical, brutal and uncompromising.


Tallara Bamblett


Another player to surprise with their youth in 2022 was Tallara Bamblett. The rangy five-eighth formed a formidable playmaking battery with Rosemarie Beckett (NRLW Development Squad) which in turn helped guide the Blue & Gold to the Grand Final Qualifier. Bamblett is at her best getting downhill and attacking the defensive line with the ball in hand but she also showed she could be counted on to distribute the ball effectively and kick with acumen.

Given that Beckett handled the primary playmaking responsibilities this year and is now moving on to the NRLW Development Squad, Bamblett will be called upon to lead a new halves partner in 2023. There could be slip-ups and stumbles in the upcoming journey but hopefully the greater share of responsibility can be the making of Tallara. She has the size, skills and frame to take the Tarsha Gale by storm and she should have the team mates around to help facilitate that next year.


Alysha Bell


Anyone following Parramatta’s journey in the 2022 Tarsha Gale premiership would have heard or read Alysha Bell’s name called dozens and dozens of times through the season. The sharpshooting winger sensationally drilled 26 of her 34 try and penalty conversion attempts (76.50%) and is without a doubt the cleanest striker of the ball that I have seen in 5 years of covering the Tarsha Gale. A background in soccer gives her the supreme edge here but she also is an experienced touch football player. She has shown herself to be accomplished winger thus far but given her multi-discipline sporting background combined with a lean, athletic frame makes me think we haven’t the best of her talents yet.

The value of scoring in 6s as opposed to 4s is, well frankly worth 50% more for each try, but should never be slept on in general and there is a very good chance that Alysha could forge a long NRLW career on that aspect alone.


Kyanna Lokeni


Tahleisha Maeva (NRLW Development Squad) and Kyanna Lokeni weren’t exactly unheralded in the breakthrough 2022 Tarsha Gale season but with plenty of other deserved stars across the park they slipped a smidgen under the radar. Maeva earned a NRLW Development contract for her efforts while Lokeni returns for her senior year of Tarsha Gale as a crucial piece in the backrow.

Kyanna showed the kind of ruggedness you love to see from an edge forward in 2022. Violent and physical runs with the ball in hand were balanced against violent and physical tackles without possession. The term I often hark back for these kinds of players is a tone-setter and Lokeni will be one of the catalysts in the forwards for the Eels in 2023.


Ashlee Pottinger

Dummy Half

If I were to simply and concisely break down Ashlee Pottinger’s game it would be in a single word – powerful. Parramatta’s dummy half terrorised the middle of the field with her power running game and posed a constant threat for markers on the goal line. Ashlee profiles closer to a Brandon Smith­ style rake than a conventional #9 but we have all certainly seen just how effective that can be at the highest levels of play.

That isn’t to say that there isn’t nuance or subtlety to her play but her calling card is smashmouth rugby league. As with Sam Tuivati last year in the Harold Matthews, I was shocked to learn that Ashlee was in her junior year of Tarsha Gale given how physically dominant she was. She will be a core piece of the 2023 squad and in the long term could feature in the NRLW as a dummy-half or the increasingly popular hybrid lock/rake utility.

If you liked this article, you might consider supporting The Cumberland Throw.

25 thoughts on “Rookie Watch 2023 Part 1 – SG Ball & Tarsha Gale

  1. Colin Hussey

    Thanks for the post 40, much appreciated.

    No doubt early days for the players mentioned so far, and something that for me provides me and likely others with insight into the younger brigade of eels.

    While I miss the big team, I also love to read and channel myself towards the up & commers, and to watch their developments as they are really our futures.

    Keep up this work as its banquet food for the future.

      1. Forty20 Post author

        Part 2 will definitely be the juicier article given that the prospects in our Jersey Flegg, NRLW Development Squad and NSW Cup are much further down their development pathways.

    1. Sterlo

      They did not require to be included in train on squad as theyre talent was obvious so they were preselected .

    2. sixties

      They have been involved in the JETS program and are likely to do some preseason training above SG Ball level.

      1. Forty20 Post author

        In their case the omission of information is important information itself! The Eels have shown a willingness to accelerate young talent if they believe they can handle the jump in difficulty (Ethan Sanders in particular exemplifies this). I expect these four young men to start 2023 in SG Ball but there could be opportunities later in the year to feature in the Jersey Flegg.

        1. MarkInTheStands

          Sure but it makes trying to look at and document squad progression difficult.

          I hope the squad has someone running the show and not waiting for the dummy half to do something and then chime in which was Matts problem last year.

  2. DK Eel

    Fantastic analysis and breakdown 40. And, like King Gutho, it’s simply what I come to expect from 40/20! I felt a genuine tingle of excitement for the future reading this, especially the section on our Tarsha Gale Players .

    I’ve become quite the fan(atic) of the women’s game over the last six years or so, and what you had to report on those players … well, I can’t wait to see them come through the ranks and make their NRLW debut .



    1. sixties

      Given that many of the Harold Matts players will be in their first season of Junior Rep footy we decided not to single out players in that grade for a profile. Forty pointed that out in the opening to this post

    2. Forty20 Post author

      Harold Matthews is the most difficult squad to profile at this time of year on two accounts. Firstly, there is typically a massive roster turnover between seasons in the Matts – far moreso than the SG Ball and Tarsha Gale. Secondly, the extra year or two of development afforded to the Ball and Gale are important when trying to make an informed projection.

      With that said there is a small contingent of returning Matts players next year. Players like Dom Farrugia, Jordan Uta, Tyson Sangalang and Zaidas Muagututia are young prospects that I am keen to see take big steps forwards in 2023.

      1. John Eel

        Last year the Eels made a big thing about the Matts squad being all home grown juniors. That is to be applauded.

        However as they get into SG Ball and higher it will become evident that some of the players that you felt were going to progress to the NRL are simply going not going to make it.

        It is at that time that the club should seriously look around for the next key players to fill the spots where players are moving on.

        Players move on because they have reached the end of their NRL career, or players move on because they are chasing bigger contracts than the club can supply.

        But sometimes players move on because the club needs more in that position than the player is giving.

        Recruitment and contract management is a highly skilled profession. You don’t always get it right.

      2. Anonymous

        Junior Fagalele seemed like a nice prospect from HM last year. Do you lads know if he’s still with the club?

  3. LSB997

    Sixties & Forty, do you think any of these juniors might have a chance of getting an NRL debut late in 2023 when they are 18? Or any of them seeing some NSW Cup even? I could see Arthur getting a run in cup late in 2023 at 14.

    1. sixties

      The goal for the male players profiled here would be getting time in Jersey Flegg. I doubt that they be rushing them higher than that.

  4. Milo

    Thanks for the read 40/20 and 60’s; and its great reading to see how they have all gone and where we see them. I just hope we have the right people in charge of development and more importantly picking the best and assisting the coaches in charge.
    We should be vying for semis in these junior teams and i know we get picked out from others but its key we have the right people getting the right players, and it starts early from the 14’s.

    1. sixties

      Cheers Milo. To this point we are seeing extra support for the coaches, and the appointment of Shepherd and Brown into key roles. I’ll be looking to find out more as soon as I can.

  5. Paul Taylor

    Hey Forty & Sixties,

    Another quality read as always. As has been already suggested , this who we keep or do we fast path is a delicate process. Would love to see some raw talented kids from say PNG or Fiji to get a proper football education , development and confidence to move through the grades hopefully towards the NRL.

    Every club has that next big thing in their club. Getting them developed without season ending injuries is the key. Body conditioning and getting bigger, stronger and certainly resilient is the key.

    1. sixties

      Paul, there could definitely be some hidden gems, but that’s what clubs have scouts for. Are they missing talent? Probably.
      Stand by for Forty’s next post as it will identify some of the players closer to NSW Cup and NRL.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

%d bloggers like this: