The Cumberland Throw

Whisky Musings – Round 4: Eels The Gurus Of Their Hoodoos As They Conquer Cronulla

Round 4 Drink Of Choice – Starward Single Malt

 

The Eels continue to build through the opening month of the 2019 season as they notched their third win, a 24-12 victory over the Cronulla Sharks, to stay a pace of the competition front-runners. Cronulla were besieged by injuries throughout the night but still gave Parramatta the gritty, grinding workout that we all expected coming into the fixture. There is little doubt that this was a game that the 2018 Eels lose and lose handily but a superb individual game from Mitchell Moses, backed up brilliantly by Clinton Gutherson, guided the Eels through the final quarter to play to the twelve point win.

Indeed, it has been a rare opening month for the Parramatta Eels with Brad Arthur guiding the club to just its fourth 3-1 start in the NRL era. Fascinatingly, the only other times the Eels have recorded such a start are in the first two years of the NRL (1998-99) and then under Arthur’s stewardship in 2016.

The strong start has the Eels positioned perfectly to consolidate throughout the middle of the season but more importantly it has given us plenty of talking points for this week’s musings.

 

http://www.starrpartners.com.au/office/starr-partners-narellan

 

The Prophet & The King

They already got a wrap in the opening paragraph but it can not be understated how impressive Mitchell Moses and Clinton Gutherson were last night. Moses was in complete control in his first outing without Dylan Brown, freely mixing composed set-plays and structures with heady responsive play to what the Cronulla defensive line was presenting him with at any given time.

Mitch finished the night with two try assists and also broke the line himself separately two other times. The Sharks had no answer to the probing questions he asked of their defence but for a player known for his panache and propensity to look for the big plays, it was his decisions to slow the game down at crucial moments that stood out.

Moses set the team up for the opportunity to ice that game with the Michael Jennings’ try by controlling the territorial battle. It remains to be seen if this was a coming-of-age performance for the mercurial halfback but the signs were nothing less than outstanding.

Also, how about those conversions? After missing two attempts against Penrith in Round 1, Moses has been flawless off the tee in the following three games and now sits at 15/17 for the season to date. Goal-kicking was one of the real question marks hanging over the Eels heading into 2019 but Moses is alleviating those concerns as it stands.

Despite his red-hot form, you wouldn’t know Moses was off-contract because there has been nary a peep in the media. Clinton Gutherson on the other hand has had his name plastered in the presses in the last couple of weeks as he and the Eels work towards finding middle ground at the negotiation table.

The reigning King of Parra hasn’t let the contract talk derail his form mind you. Gutherson continues to validate the second-season theory for ACL recoveries as he elevates his game to heights perhaps even beyond what he achieved in 2017. It usually takes a herculean effort to top Blake Ferguson for metres on the ground and Gutherson provided just that as he cranked out 265m from 20 carries and remained ever present as a support runner for his other offensive weapons.

It will be missed in the annals of history but he also played a crucial role in one of the greatest tries that never was with Kane Evans barely failing to finish off a length of the field effort from a kickoff before half-time. It might be an outrageous hot-take but I think this Gutherson kid might be alright.

 

The Mountain That Strides

Fans around the world are waiting with bated breaths as Game Of Thrones enters its climatic season in the coming weeks. Gregor Clegane, aka The Mountain That Rides, might be a poor comparison for Junior Paulo given his role as a villain in the show but the two share a rare ability and potential for physical dominance.

Paulo bullied the Sharks on both sides of the ball, nearly scoring a sensational individual try and tattooing Scott Sorenson with an imprint of his shoulders in a belter of a hit. The mountainous prop forward has been nothing short of outstanding in the first month of footy and it seems like the Eels are constantly looking for means to expand his role in their offensive systems. Against the Roosters and Bulldogs he was given freedom to attack down the edges and pass while last night Mitchell Moses consistently looked to turn the ball back inside to him.

He hasn’t been left to do it all by himself with the rest of the forward pack providing more than adequate support but Paulo has the potential to tilt the field as a prop and the Eels seem resolute to uncover his full potential as a game-breaker.

 

Salmon Steady At Stand-Off

Dylan Brown probably raised the bar to an unfair height but Jaeman Salmon was exceptionally tidy playing in relief of Brown last night. Salmon handled the secondary kicking duties neatly, took on all the traffic the Sharks directed his way and was a tireless presence in support.

He came close to scoring on two occasions as he backed up line breaks by Mitchell Moses and Clinton Gutherson only to be denied at the last moment. It wasn’t a jaw-dropping performance by any means but Salmon has been pushing for a greater role for the last two weeks and he certainly didn’t drop his bundle last night.

The timeline on Dylan’s recovery is somewhat shrouded in mystery although there has been speculation of a 6-8 week monitoring period. Parramatta need Salmon to maintain this level of play at five-eighth as the foil to Moses but I am hoping he can go above and beyond as he finds his feet in a starting role.

 

Mannah’s Monstrous Run

Given that they were playing for the Johnny Mannah Cup, it is fair to say that is was a big night for club stalwart Tim Mannah. Cronulla have mostly had a monopoly on the trophy dedicated to his deceased brother but Tim made sure the Eels reclaimed it as he delivered a road-grader 30m+ run that left multiple defenders strewn in his wake. It laid the platform for Michael Jennings to score the try, his first of two, that broke the deadlock and signaled a match-winning swing in momentum for the night.

Mannah continues to enjoy a renaissance period in his career as he carves out a terrific niche on the bench. Paul Gallen credited the Parramatta bench with outplaying Cronulla’s interchange forwards on the Sunday Footy Show today and Mannah certainly led the way there.

 

Potentially Costly Errors Still There But Defence Lifts

The Eels finished Saturday night with a solid completion rate of 83% as they get through 33 of a possible 40 sets. The improved discipline was certainly a factor in stymieing all of Cronulla’s comeback efforts but Parramatta certainly gifted them enough chances regardless. Blake Ferguson delivered a scathing self-assessment on the field after allowing Sosaia Feki to score off a grubber kick while both Maika Sivo and Kane Evans turned the ball over coming out of the redzone.

Barring an embarrassing lapse that allowed Feki to post his second try from a penalty tap, the Eels defended their goal line staunchly in an encouraging bounce back from Round 3 where they let the Roosters cross for some soft points.

I have made the case for this already in my musings this season but the Eels are 100% a work in progress. The fact they sit at 3-1 is a credit to their coach Brad Arthur, his support staff and the players. As they iron out these errors and grow in confidence in defence they will begin to solidify their claim to a berth in the upper echelons of the ladder.

 

The Final Word

At the start of the season we all of course predicted that next Sunday’s twilight game against the Canberra Raiders would be played with a spot in the Top 4 at stake. Completely rational, insightful and intelligent is what you would have been labelled as without a doubt.

Yet here we are.

Round 5 is now circled as a massive game as Parramatta get the chance to open an early break on the lower parts of the ladder and set-up a barn burner Easter Monday game against the Wests-Tigers in front of a sold-out home crowd at Bank West Stadium.

Canberra’s potent weapons on the edges and busy backrowers will keep the Eels honest but Parramatta have a legitimate chance to knock off a second bogey team in consecutive weeks if they play anything like they have in the first month of 2019.

 

 

 

17
Click Here to Reply ...

avatar
8 Comment threads
9 Thread replies
1 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
10 Comment authors
Forty20JimMilo!0 Year MemberJohn Eel Recent comment authors
  Subscribe  
newest oldest most voted
Notify of
Milo
Guest
Milo

What a great read forty and a huge thank you to yourself and the team there. Yes its early on in the season but gee the players the coaching staff have brought in are paying some form of dividends. Junior, Lane, Ferguson and of course Sivo who will only get better. Interesting comments from Gallen about our bench and to me this is a key area; we need to have them coming on with the impact and it seems they have done this. I look forward to the next weekend and think we are a v good chance of beating… Read more »

Parrastew
Guest
Parrastew

Another enjoyable read fourty20 win or lose I always look forward to whisky musings. May I suggest a drink from left field ‘Glenn Marnoch 21 year old single malt’ a suprisingly good drop from the unknown distillery’s of Aldi .

Big Derek
Guest
Big Derek

One of the stranger things this game presented, was the commentary continually talking about Sharks fielding a young inexperienced team, and according to Mr Kent we have only won games as the sides we play are full of injuries and short handed. Stats tell a different story, the Parramatta team was on average younger, and at the same time played on average less NRL games. There is no need to,get carried awatpy as there is a long way to go, but as your musings suggest, the team is a work in progress and BA and his staff deserve credit for… Read more »

Colin Hussey
Guest
Colin Hussey

Ignore the eels old one game wonder expert and what he says as its on par with his football playing ability.
Thing is he’s not the only one on a similar bandwagon as almost every media report I have read was talking about how injury ravaged the sharks were, with 4 NRL players out, we are in the same boat with similar numbers, but not mentioned.

John Eel
Guest
John Eel

Good points by both Derek and Col but it is not just Kent. The media in general had us written off and as a result have done little analysis on the Eels potential for 2019.

The Fox commentary in general was good however they only attributed injury concerns to the Sharks. Did not mention the young Eels under 20 or the lack of experience for Sivo even though he is 25 years old.

Milo
Guest
Milo

Yes I can agree with these comments and I only assume that they the media have Gallen, Moylan, Graham etc as more important in terms of salary cap..to their team than us with our injuries. I don’t agree but I can only assume this is their logic.

DDay
Guest
DDay

The Eels look threatening across the park. We can be a real force as this team develops its’ attack systems. We’ve let a couple of soft tries apparently due to lapses in attention, which should be fixable. I like the WIP argument.

John Eel
Guest
John Eel

This is not meant to be a criticism of the referee because they all seem to do the same thing.

What was disappointing and I have seen this play out before, was the time that Jr pushed forward at the line. He got across the line but was pushed back. He did not claim a try but instead got up quickly to play the ball.

The referee then stopped the game and went to the bunker. This action took away all of the Eels momentum.

Why do the referees persist in going to the bunker instead of “play on”?

!0 Year Member
Guest
!0 Year Member

Enimem (taking on the line) and the King (we might have to call him energiser bunny, he is everywhere and backing up everything) did have great games. I also think MJ was impressive, to turn up on the opposite side of the field to score the match sealer was impressive. I wish I could turn around my personal fortunes as good as my beloved Eels have turn their around. Keep it up lads, you are doing us supporters very proud. 1 to 17 were superb, everyone doing their job for the team. Just love watching them when they play like… Read more »

John Eel
Guest
John Eel

I don’t think Kaufusi registered a carry in his short stint at the end of the game. He certainly lined up for a few but did not get the ball.

He is a big unit and has a lot of ability so I hope he gets more game time in the future . I was impressed with his last game in 2018

Jim
Guest
Jim

Funny thing is Dave Faulkner from the Hoodoo Gurus is a massive sharks fan.