Here we go again Manly and Parra….
Those of us who were around in the early 80s would have loved reliving that great old Tooheys commercial that was screened again on Fox League during the week. Any Eels supporters too young to remember, or even born since, might have difficulty fathoming how high profile the Eels of that era were. Perhaps it should be a message to potential sponsors nowadays, because the marketing gurus back then certainly realised the reach of a successful Parramatta team.
If you haven’t seen the adverts, you can view the second in the series here
So back to that Sea Eagles and Eels rivalry.
Both clubs entered the premiership in the same year, 1947. However, the paths of the two clubs could not have been any more different.
Whilst Parramatta’s early years featured a succession of wooden spoons, and no finals appearances until 1962, Manly would reach their first grand final in 1951 and have yet to finish at the bottom of the Premiership table. The Sea Eagles have totalled eight titles, double that of the Eels, and have lifted the trophy in every decade since the 1970s. In contrast, Parra’s four premierships were achieved across six seasons in the 1980s, with nothing to show since 1986.
Yet, the two clubs have one of league’s greatest rivalries. Why? Apart from entering the competition together, the two clubs seem to symbolise the polar opposites of rugby league.
In the early years, it was the wealthy northern beaches club against the battlers from the west. Manly seemed to build their early titles from plundering the talent of clubs like South Sydney and later Western Suburbs. They became the club that everyone loved to hate.
In contrast, Parramatta’s successful era featured some of the greatest one club or junior players. It was almost destiny that Manly would be the club to deny the Eels under controversial circumstances in the 1976 decider, and would again be the rival receiving the better end of the calls in the clashes between the clubs during the infamous 1978 finals series. (Seven tackles anyone?)
So by the time the 1982 and 1983 seasons rolled around, the rivalry between the clubs had peaked to such an extent that it would be immortalised in that series of Tooheys advertisements.
Fast forward to today.
The wealth of the two clubs has undoubtedly been reversed. The Eels have a financial benefactor in the form of a highly successful leagues club, whereas the Sea Eagles have required privatisation to stay afloat. Whilst Manly’s commercial issues haven’t hindered their successes, they are no longer the true Silvertails of the premiership.
Back to the business at hand.
For this Round 1 Stat Attack, I’m going to look at recent history and the last 10 matches between these two great rivals.
| Season | Round | Match name | Eels Score | Manly Score | Venue name | Result |
| 2016 | 22 | Eels vs Sea Eagles | 10 | 9 | Pirtek Stadium | Eels win by 1 points |
| 2016 | 7 | Sea Eagles vs Eels | 22 | 10 | Brookvale Oval | Eels win by 12 points |
| 2015 | 24 | Sea Eagles vs Eels | 20 | 16 | Brookvale Oval | Eels win by 4 points |
| 2015 | 1 | Eels vs Sea Eagles | 42 | 12 | Pirtek Stadium | Eels win by 30 points |
| 2014 | 24 | Eels vs Sea Eagles | 22 | 12 | Pirtek Stadium | Eels win by 10 points |
| 2014 | 3 | Sea Eagles vs Eels | 18 | 22 | Brookvale Oval | Sea Eagles win by 4 points |
| 2013 | 21 | Eels vs Sea Eagles | 6 | 40 | Pirtek Stadium | Sea Eagles win by 34 points |
| 2013 | 17 | Sea Eagles vs Eels | 10 | 50 | Brookvale Oval | Sea Eagles win by 40 points |
| 2012 | 18 | Sea Eagles vs Eels | 24 | 40 | Brookvale Oval | Sea Eagles win by 16 points |
| 2012 | 5 | Eels vs Sea Eagles | 29 | 20 | Pirtek Stadium | Eels win by 9 points |
In the last 10 matches the Eels hold a slender 6 to 4 lead but who are we kidding – a lead is a lead ,especially over this mob.
The Eels two recent visits to Brookvale Oval, or should I say Lottoland, have served them well with two wins and no doubt the boys will be amped in continuing this trend on Sunday.
Points wise over these last 10 outings, Parra’s 203 trails Manly’s 231. Averaged out, this gives Manly the lead 23 – 20.
Overall, there’s been 136 matches between the clubs, with Manly holding a 82 to 50 winning record. At Brookvale, they’ve played 64 times with Manly holding a decisive 42 – 21 winning record.
Many ‘experts’ are tipping Manly to have a much-improved year. With only one quality signing in Blake Green, it’s hard to see them as a major player in this year’s premiership. Manly have lost an astonishing 820 games of experience with the retirements of Jamie Lyon, Brett Stewart and Steve Matai. This is something that cannot be replaced with a quick stop solution. They will be sorely missed.
As for Parramatta, they have signed quality. Although the names are not high profile, they are intelligent signings. Matagi, Brown and Frank Pritchard bring size, mobility and ball playing to the Eels forward pack and Josh Hoffman brings speed, experience and is a noted try scorer.
Yet many ‘experts’ have the Eels as bottom of the 8 or missing the 8 completely. Their rationale points to the pairing of Gutherson and Norman in the halves. Norman Is rightly acknowledged for his talent, but they see Gutherson as a potential problem. However, as we saw at the end of last year and through Sixties’ summer training reports, there is no doubt Gutherson can hold his own.
With wet weather predicted and a heavy track, this could be a closer game than people would think but I can see our forwards dominating and running riot over their Manly counterparts and our backs to feed of this momentum.
I will be there Sunday. Hope you will too. We need to be the best supporters in the NRL and show that the Blue and Gold Army do travel and support our team. We cannot underestimate the boost that this gives to our team.
We have an important role in making Parra great.
When we support our team in numbers, it reminds marketers and sponsors of Parramatta’s market reach that was so readily recognised back in those TV commercials.
HERE WE GO AGAIN…..
Colmac
Champion Data
Follow @championdatanrl
mc.championdata.com/nrl/
Apps: Telstra Sportsfan, Triple M NRL


New year and both teams have new players, an article this morning in one media papre with Tepai shows the eels players are ready, so let the action start.
I would love to be there but will be in the sense by being in front of the box watching – cheering and the like. I am as always looking to the eels to win however following last seasons twin losses poor form and the like, along with the likelihood of a heavy track this game is harder to predict.
Too many have written off the gulls owing to experience thats been lost, but realistically how many games did Steweat, Matai play in last year, and Lyon was also out for a while as well, so they wont really be missing them as they did last year. Some in the team have points to prove as well, they will rely on the skull in Myles and Tapau big time and depending on how they go things will be tight.
I expect an eels win and hope for it to happen some aspects may be determined by the 27thman though.
I expect an Eels victory Colin, but I take nothing for granted. We are missing a couple of key forwards, though I expect both Danny and Rory to go well.
27th man? Hope not. Though could he be called 35th man in today’s game?
Mate,, I thought of the 35th, hope no influence on the game. I think our forwards should more than hold their own, and with Kaysa being nippy out of dummy half could cause problems.
To me perhaps the key area is who gets on top in the halves, Manly are perhaps in front there with more experienced players. Gutho will have more to prove against his old club but up against an experienced campaigner, same with Corey against DCE will be a very intriguing match up.
I also look to an eels win.