The Cumberland Throw

From The Stands – April 20, 2021: Eels Defy History Whilst Repeat Offenders March On

On Saturday my family ventured to the nation’s capital to support our Eels but if I am absolutely truthful I did not really know what to expect.

I have referred to Parra’s visits down to Canberra in the past as “entering the Bermuda triangle”.  They have always managed to get lost even in those games in which they have started well.

After the first five minutes I could tell the boys were going to have a real go and as a supporter that is what I expect. If I see that in my team they will always have our support no matter the scoreboard.

Sitting in the stands we had a wonderful night. I have always found the Raiders a really good fan base and there was much good natured banter back and forth in the stands, just as it should be.  

As the game progressed we kept waiting for Parra to get carried away, play pretty football and start crabbing sideways, but to their absolute credit they did not. They stayed pretty much in the middle corridor 20 metres either side of the post and just kept throwing multiple players at the Raiders defenders waiting for them to make the wrong choice. 


I would argue that even the second try scored by Maika was set up by the first try and us playing primarily in that middle corridor. The Raiders players had to cover the Parra forwards on the short side and this left Maika open and Gutherson threw a wonderful pass right on his chest.

You could see the effort, the players ran hard, our playmakers took the ball to the line and held the ball when the pass was not on and our long kicking game and chase was simply superb.

There was one chase in the second half that was wonderful.  It happened right in front of us as we had tickets at the end the Eels ran to in the second half. Moses put in a long kick and Rapana tried to get out of the corner, Marata and Fergo ran down and inside them Will Smith, Junior and Nathan Brown kept up, creating a straight line to keep them trapped near the sideline.

We compressed our defence and they made very little ground that set.  Everyone did their job.

From the stands you could easily single out Moses but I think that would be unfair. He played very well but he did that because our forwards laid the foundation, our outside men retrieved  the ball from kicks really well and got our sets started strongly, we held the ball, did not force risky offloads and we rewarded Moses kicks by chasing in a straight line.

I left this game feeling the same as I did after our victory against the Storm.

This is how we play, this is what will win us big games, this is our point of difference.

To win big games, effort is not enough. You have to be slick, you have to be sure and you have to be able to hold your nerve.  In any field of work holding your nerve under pressure comes through practice and repetition.

It has been interesting watching the Storm this year as they lost to both the Panthers and the Eels. They lost their nerve and when the pressure was mounted their playmakers made bad choices.

Of course this demonstrates just how crucial Cameron Smith was for them, as although I could not stand watching him play I always recognised his ability to make the right pass and kick in those big pressure moments. 

To me this premiership is so wide open as the top 5 teams, excluding the Roosters who I don’t believe can win the title without Keary, all play very different football but all have weaknesses. 

The Rabbits have lethal backs, the Panthers play so quick and have high possession rates, the Storm have such big forwards who offload to quick outside backs, the Raiders have a forward pack that can roll down field and we have a pack that can dominate and quick playmakers who can play off the back of that.

From the Stands this competition is there to be taken but the team that will eventually win it will use the regular season to perfect their strengths and will almost go into auto pilot in the big games.

The next two games will be very interesting for our Eels against weaker opposition. How will they play? Will they stay in the middle? In truth they may be able to win and do just enough playing fancy football but it will only limit their opportunities to perfect their strengths and while they will get the points they will miss opportunities.

Melbourne and the Roosters have been the benchmarks over the past decade because they have played the same way against the top and bottom teams. It will be interesting to see if our Eels can be as disciplined in the next two weeks as they were against the Raiders.

My last comment from the stands this week is simple  but I think the most important one.

Matto hasn’t played since his concussion

I applaud the Eels for looking after the welfare of Ryan Matterson as our first and only concern. Matterson makes our 17 much better but short and long term health is always more important when compared to a game of footy.

Over the weekend and in previous weeks it has been concerning to watch how some clubs use the HIA by either removing players for a free interchange or keeping them on when they should be taken off to be checked properly.

I believe my club is doing the right thing as they have with Matterson but I will also call them out if they ever do the wrong thing.

Deliberately manipulating rules, such as milking a penalty in a game can be called a tactic and that will always happen by every club in probably every game.

However, if clubs or their staff are deliberately manipulating rules that are put in place to protect the safety of a player, it is a sackable and criminal offence in an ordinary workplace.

Therefore any club official or club who deliberately manipulates HIA should not be allowed in our game and any player who partakes is this should not be welcomed either. Sometimes people need to be protected from themselves and I for one cannot understand how any player would want to make a mockery of a rule that is entirely designed to protect their long term health from what is both known and unknown impacts.

Of course the cynic in me expects the NRL to come out with strong words and put clubs on notice. Over the next couple of weeks they will probably punish a lowly performing club to make a public point and let the big and high flying clubs go unpunished from this round even after we all clearly saw with our own eyes the manipulation of this most important safety rule.

Unfortunately, history is the best indicator of future behaviour and there are clubs in our competition who continually push the line and bend/ manipulate rules with little to no remorse.

I sincerely hope that, should such behaviour continue, actual impactful punishment is dished out to them by the NRL.




If you liked this article, you might consider supporting The Cumberland Throw.
Notify of
newest most voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

Our control of this game was outstanding, we were disciplined, sensible and hard working for the length of the match, a full eighty minute performance that hopefully is a “coming of age” and not a “one off”.


Great summary of the game Shelley.

Agree with your last two paragraphs. I saw a fullback on Friday night facedown and unconcious on the ground. I had the sound down so didnt get the commentary but I was flabbagasted to see him back in the game later. Most players are gone from the game for far less. That player was later instrumental in the win. Congratulations but where is the consistency in player welfare?


I have no idea if any of those players were acting to get a penalty or if they were genuinely concussed. Accepting a club saying trust us he was only acting to get a penalty opens Pandora’s box. Any club could always use this excuse to explain away not bringing a person from the field. We also much draw a line in the sand- if a player wants to act to get a penalty or sin bin then they can spend 15 minutes in HIA. That will soon stop it

Mr controversy aka rev

Good right up Shelley. I agree with you we play much better if we just roll up our sleeves n roll over the top of team’s. As other would say we are just a dry track bullies. For me that’s not right. We beat Melbourne n Canberra 2 teams that no one gave us a chance to win. Yet we one buy playing straight line defense. We can still play pretty but we still have to play thru tje middle. I didn’t see the game can.u tell me hpw reedy went please. Jis running from DH more I’ve seen it’s… Read more »


We need to get our opposition thinking about how we could play. I like how we started to offload and spread it wider in the second half once we had tired them out by simply holding the ball and hammering them in the middle.


Good write up Shelley & gutsy effort going down to Bruce stadium. We won thru the middle and by having 13 players on the field all doing their job – good line speed, good kick chase and we stuck to the game plan. Plenty of points in those Eels when they get over the top of the opposition pack.


Shelley, you make some good strong points particularly when dealing with workplace issues. As there was a reluctance to punish, for want of a better word, Brisbane in the past more so with Bennett in charge it is the same with Melbourne Storm. If the Storm could find a way to manipulate the rules then they are always the forerunners. I can’t quite believe how they get away with it and at the same time wear a halo. I think because they are surrounded by AFL the NRL apply leniency with this club. Certainly they don’t like being called on… Read more »


Play acting for a penalty is irrelevant. They fell to the ground unprotected and took time to get up. They needed to come off and if they were acting that will stop them doing it in a big game.

John Eel

Good read again Shelley. I particularly like your point on the next two weeks games. We need to play with the power game philosophy and stick with until as you say it becomes habit. The try that Lane scored came about because of sticking to the game plan and forcing the Raiders to do a lot of heavy defence. Once the Eels started to move the ball around the Raiders had no energy left to man up in defence . That was some Try. The more practiced they get at the Power game the more susceptible teams will be in… Read more »


It will be interesting to see how they go. I do have confidence but they have to respect both the opposition and also their own style of play

Would love your thoughts, please comment.x