The Cumberland Throw

Stat Attack Review – Round 3: Eels vs Titans

Eels 14 defeated by Titans 26

Crowd: 11,612

 

Well what more can really be said that already hasn’t been uttered, cursed or muttered a 100 times already?

There is no doubt that there are many words or phrases that could describe the performance on Friday night by the Eels – but we are not going to dwell on that. You pick yourself up, dust yourself off and get back to work.

So just what happens to the Eels when they play the Titans??? Why on Earth do the Titans have the wood over the Eels? With 16 games now played between these clubs, the Titans hold a huge 11-5 head-to-head lead . Did we miss Norman that much? Would he have really made a difference? Did our brilliant start get the players thinking ‘This is going to be easy’ which in turn led to the them throwing the game plan out the window?

So many questions can be asked. Still, after the dust settles on the carnage of the Friday night ambush the Eels are sitting 4th on the ladder and that is a bloody good achievement after three consecutive away games to start the season.

Let’s delve into the stats that matter for Parramatta.

Scoring Stats:

Parramatta Eels
H Minute Name Event Score
1 8 C.Gutherson TRY 0 – 4
1 9 C.Gutherson CONVERSION 0 – 6
1 15 J.Robson TRY 0 – 10
1 17 C.Gutherson CONVERSION 0 – 12
1 27 C.McQueen TRY 4 – 12
1 29 A.Taylor CONVERSION 6 – 12
1 40 T.Cornish TRY 10 – 12
1 40 A.Taylor CONVERSION 12 – 12
2 44 C.Gutherson PENALTY GOAL 12 – 14
2 51 K.Elgey TRY 16 – 14
2 53 A.Taylor CONVERSION 18 – 14
2 56 A.Taylor PENALTY GOAL 20 – 14
2 73 T.Roberts TRY 24 – 14
2 74 A.Taylor CONVERSION 26 – 14

 

Full Time:

 GC Team Stats  PAR

52

Possession (%)

48
29/36 (81) Complete/Total Sets (%)

25/35 (71)

42:58 Time – Opposition Half

38:52

18:52

Time – Opposition 20 15:46
1767 Metres Gained

1687

11

Scrum Win 8
2 Goal Line Dropout

0

6

Penalty Conceded

8

0 Forty Twenty

0

 

It definitely makes for a different read when compared to last weeks’ game against the Dragons. The Titans just dominated everything against Parramatta and the Eels simply couldn’t respond.

Poor unforced errors really killed any momentum the Eels were trying to start and the constant turnovers proved to be an insurmountable hurdle for a team bereft of its chief shot-caller.

Considerable congratulations must go out to the Titans. They played a terrifc game under incredible adversity as they battled a damaging injury toll.

 

1st Half:

 

 GC Team Stats  PAR

50

Possession (%) 50
13/18 (72) Complete/Total Sets (%)

14/18 (78)

26:47

Time – Opposition Half 14:58
10:00

Time – Opposition 20

9:59

845

Metres Gained 911
5 Scrum Win

4

2

Goal Line Dropout 0
1 Penalty Conceded

5

0

Forty Twenty

0

 

The opening 15 mins makes the first half stats look pretty good. Decent completion rates had us in the game at half time. However as you can see with the Time-in-opposition-half numbers, this is where the Titans began to wrest control of the game from the Eels. Our last 20 mins was pretty poor.

 

2nd Half:

 

 GC Team Stats  PAR

55

Possession (%) 45
16/18 (89) Complete/Total Sets (%)

11/17 (65)

16:11

Time – Opposition Half 23:54
8:52 Time – Opposition 20

5:47

922

Metres Gained 776
6 Scrum Win

4

0

Goal Line Dropout 0
5 Penalty Conceded

3

0

Forty Twenty

0

 

Not much to say here for the second half. Great completion rate from the Titans but what is really surprising is that we had quality time in the Titans’ half but did absolutely nothing with it. Again, it likely speaks towards both an inconsistent platform from our forwards and a lack of direction from our halves.

 

Attack:

 

Top 5 Runs
Name R
 PAR S.Matagi 15
 GC K.Hurrell 14
 GC R.James 13
 GC C.McQueen 13
 PAR M.Ma’u 12
Top 5 Run Metres
Name RM
 GC K.Hurrell 125
 PAR B.Takairangi 121
 PAR S.Matagi 116
 PAR T.Mannah 113
 GC C.McQueen 112

 

Rarely does the match-up between Eels and Titans make for easy viewing. Neither team tend to put on an array of fluent attacking movements when we match up and it usually falls into a dour grind. Friday was no different.

Four Eels made the magic 100 metres for this game, with two (French and Ma’u) also falling just short back in the 90’s. For their part, only two Titans ran for over 100 metres.

 

Brad Takairangi 121m
Suaia Matagi 116m
Tim Mannah 113m
Josh Hoffman 105m

 

It was surprising to see that in this game we opted to use our right-edge attack so heavily. In our previous two games the left-edge has been our dominant attacking side – although this is of course should take into account the massive variable that is the presence of Corey Norman. Both our right-edge players both made over 100 metres while the left was not as prominent. On top of two uncharacteristic errors, Semi only ran for 51m while Jennings was slightly busier with 75m. Very quiet production from our left-edge attack.

 

Defence:

 

Top 5 Tackles
SID Name TAK
 GC R.James 46
 GC J.Wallace 36
 GC K.Proctor 35
 PAR M.Ma’u 35
 PAR B.Scott 29
Top 5 Missed Tackles
SID Name MT
 GC A.Taylor 4
 GC K.Elgey 4
 GC J.Wallace 3
 PAR T.Mannah 3
 PAR J.Hoffman 2

 

Nine Eels made 20 or more tackles in the game. Our forwards and bench again shared the work load in defence, even with Rory O’Brien not taking to the field. It is truly good to see our forwards sharing the defensive work load.

Both our halves in Gutherson and Robson are included in this group. The Titans clearly had a game plan early on in the piece that targeted runs at our halves, especially Robson. I thought both had outstanding defensive games for halves. Gutherson with 27 tackles no misses, Robson 21 tackles 2 misses. Might fine effort lads.

 

Eels: 308 tackles – 14 missed tackles.

Titans: 282 tackles – 24 missed tackles.

 

All in all Round 3 won’t go down as a great round for a lot of clubs to be perfectly frank (the Cowboys and Sharks are also licking their wounds after also suffering similar ambushes). But for the Eels it will be doubly disappointing, especially with how the season started. Mind you, the saying you don’t win premierships in March rings loud and true for a good reason.

Looking forwards, what would be great to see is the Sharks slumping to a 1-3 opening record in their title defence after a thorough beating at the hands of the Eels.

After three long rounds on the road the Eels finally come back to Sydney for the first home game (in their new home away from home). So lets get out to ANZ on Saturday night and have a huge crowd on hand to watch what should be a high quality game.

Corey Norman is back (and Peni Terepo will also be elibilge for selection after serving his internal 3-game suspension) and although will be without Tepai Moeroa due to his suspension for a shoulder charge, there is little doubt that both sides will be ripping in hard after disappointing losses.

 

STAT ATTACK: PLAYER OF THE WEEK

 

 

CLINT GUTHERSON

 

No matter how a game unfolds, you can be rest assured Clint will give 100%.

Gutho is always there in the mix trying his utmost to get the team across the line. He is in the very early stages of a career in the halves and let us all not forget that most ‘experts’ had already written him off as a 5/8 and were looking at him to be the weakest point if the Eels failed to fire.

Clint’s season has started out brilliantly and I can only see him getting better as he gets more game time.

Get on the ‘Guth Bus’

Tries 1
Goals 3 (2 conversions, 1 penalty)
Points Scored 10
Possessions 41
Offloads 2
Runs (Metres) 7 (73m)
Line Breaks 1
Kicks (Metres) 8 (231m)
Tackles Made 27
Minutes Played 80

 

Champion Data

Stats courtesy of Champion Data. All these stats and more can be viewed on our match centre at http://mc.championdata.com/nrl/ including live game stats.

– Colmac

Champion Data

Follow @championdatanrl

mc.championdata.com/nrl/

If you liked this article, you might consider supporting The Cumberland Throw.

10 thoughts on “Stat Attack Review – Round 3: Eels vs Titans

  1. Colin Hussey

    Thanks for the report 40’s, a read of it does nothing really to ease the pain but its now dun’ n’ dusted, sad really with Tepai, as I think he had a busy game and is coping some undeserved flack for his game. To me its good to get that sort of game out of he way early in the season so a new week and new game.

    Same with Taka coping flack, I believe he deserved it for his misreads in defence but he made some hard a strong meters in attack but the support was not there. Also the quietness of the left side may have been good owing to Semi bringing a pack of butterfingers into the match.

    We look forward now to the reigning premiers, at (sort of) home, both will have a lot to prove, and more especially pride to restore, it will be a good hard game. Not getting any vibes at the moment as to who will win but, as always I will be backing the eels.

      1. Colin Hussey

        Ok, I’m over it I gotta find something else to support trying to keep on an even keel being an eels supporter is finally taking its effect.

  2. Anonymous

    Anyone know why Obrien wasn’t used at all? I’m dumbfounded that after a very short turn around we only use 16 Players, and losing Kaysa only increased the workload on the remaining 15.

    It seems Arthur has reservations about using Obrien, and if he is chosen ahead of Vave, Terepo or even Auva’a this week, I’ll eat my hat in disbelief ! 😦😦😦😦

  3. Paul Nixon

    The Eels had a 5 day turnaround and had to travel to Qld. Cory out too. Sure they could of won without him but with only 5 day turnaround, didn’t give much time for Robson to prepare. Take half of the mistakes away, I reckon we would of won. It’s an easy fix. Nothing to worry about really but as Tim Mannah said, it’s a missed opportunity.

    1. Colin Hussey

      Some suggestion that he picked up an injury during the warm up.

      Yes we were down to 16 men for the whole game, but the Titans also had their injury problems, several times they were out on their feet but lifted enough to get the win.

      Certainly the short turn round had the eels at a disadvantage something the nrl said with the rearrangement of when the teams play, but its nothing more than a shifting of Titanics deck chairs..

      My belief is that the teams that play on Sundays should play at least no earlier than the following Saturday’s fixtures, give the Thursday night teams the same amount of time between games by dropping them back to Saturday or the Sunday matches.

      In saying that, at least from my perspective If the way the NRL overall comp is going and that is professional and players are full time RL contracted players they are expected to play under extreme conditions of all types, and the level of training and fitness needs to be considered for them as well.

      Thing is that it adds an extra equation into the level the game is played at these days, the aspect that O’Brien was injured in the warm up and not be allowed to be replaced is very poor, but that’s part of the new set up the NRL has put in place. We all know that teams in the past have had this late replacement issue that caused this change, but when its a genuine injury there should be means for another on field neutral medico to be able to asses the genuineness of the injury, if genuine then a late replacement should be allowed so both teams start on equal footing.

      A work round perhaps could be that the team with the injured player could be assessed by the opposition doctor to give a green light. Doctors have a code of ethics they need to stick to which means they have to be unbiased in the examinations and report.

      1. Chief

        Obrien couldn’t have been too injured, he actually played in the Wentworthvile game on Sunday 😕😕😕😕

        1. Colin Hussey

          interesting! I asked the question regarding why he did not play at least three time on 1eeyed and one answer came in that he sustained an injury in warm up.

          Personally my view is that its a slap in the fact to him if he did not get a run on and there was nothing wrong with him, doesn’t do much for his confidence either.

          I suppose by the time that he was due to come on that the Titans were in command and why put someone else through the same amount of misery as the other 16.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

%d bloggers like this: